David Hume pointed out that rationality cannot tell you what your goals should be; the appeal to extraordinary evidence for extraordinary claims (per Carl Sagan) is a practical application of Bayesian reasoning to the case of reported miracles, where prior improbability is so high that testimony alone is unlikely to overcome it.

definitionpending

Speaker

Stephen Pinker

Evidence Quote

“Carl Sagan's motto extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence itself a pithy uh distillation of a point made by Hume”

Source

Steven Pinker Meets Richard Dawkins | On Reason and Rationality— How To Academy
Created: 8/11/2026, 1:18:49 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...