causal

Reason Must Track Truth to Be Selected

Even though reason is social in origin and doesn't follow strict logical validity or Bayesianism, the exchange of reasons must on average lead to more accurate beliefs (or fitness-enhancing outcomes), otherwise it would not have been selected for; people's intuitions about good versus bad reasons therefore must track what is actually true.

causalpending

Speaker

Hugo Mercier

Evidence Quote

“the intuitions people have about what is a good reason or what is a bad reason, must somehow track what is actually true. Because otherwise we would not be doing it.”

Source

233 | Hugo Mercier on Reasoning and Skepticism— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:11:55 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...