definition

Substantive Works Versus Instrumental Knowledge

Human knowledge divides into substantive works (a Byron poem, a Bach piece, Hamlet) that are fixed entities whose telos lies within themselves and whose loss is as tragic as losing a person, versus instrumental knowledge (scientific laws, historical biography) whose telos is an external truth, which can be collaboratively improved, debunked, and replaced as merely getting closer to the goal—so the real distinction in Arcadia is not science versus poetry but substantive versus instrumental knowledge.

definitionpending

Speaker

Anna Gát

Evidence Quote

“The telos of Bach is contained in itself; or maybe it's about God, like, something more than human.”

Source

Conversation, Interintellect, and Arcadia (with Anna Gat)— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:09:39 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...