causal
Mary the color scientist knowledge argument
Mary, a genius color scientist who knows everything neuroscience can teach about color experience but has lived in a black-and-white room, learns something new when she first sees color; if materialism were true neuroscience would give a complete account leaving nothing to learn, but since she gains new information about the qualitative character of color experience that could not be obtained from neuroscience, the neuroscientific account must be incomplete.
causalpending
Speaker
Philip GoffEvidence Quote
“if materialism is true, then in principle, neuroscience ought to be able to give us a complete story of the essential nature of color experience... And yet, when she comes out of her room, she does gain some new information”
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:10:44 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...