normative

Determinism Puts Punishment on Scientific Basis

Recognizing determinism does not eliminate responsibility or the ability to influence behavior; instead it places the criminal justice system on a scientific footing—since voluntary behavior can be discouraged by punishment (like a dog that stops approaching when kicked, or a driver responding to parking fines)—allowing rational investigation of deterrence, sequestration, and rehabilitation while removing only vindictive retribution.

normativepending

Speaker

Jerry Coyne

Evidence Quote

“what i like about determinism ... is because it puts the whole system of punishment rewards especially criminal punishment rewards on on a scientific basis ... the only thing we get rid of is ... punishment for retribution”

Source

10 - Faith Vs. Fact— Making Sense with Sam Harris
Created: 6/14/2026, 1:44:55 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...