factual

Scientific Communities Conservatively Police Allowable Questions

Despite being self-described liberals, academics act conservatively in their research: communities agree not only on answers but on which questions are even allowed to be asked; in the 1980s searching for planets was not considered respectable science, could not get funding or telescope time, and the same justifications used successfully today might not have succeeded then, illustrating how social value judgments gate scientific progress and may cause us to miss discoverable things.

factualpending

Speaker

John Asher Johnson

Evidence Quote

“there's an agreed upon set of questions that one is allowed to ask. And asking what fraction of those stars out there have planets around them, was not really seen as a valid question.”

Source

204 | John Asher Johnson on Hunting for Exoplanets— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:15:55 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...