normative

Defer to Your Prior Self on Disagreement

When you encounter a disagreement with someone you antecedently considered a peer, the rational response is to defer to what your past self would have judged about who is likely right conditional on such a disagreement occurring—asking a less-than-fully-specified version of the question so you don't simply reproduce the original problem—rather than always going 50/50 or always sticking to your guns.

normativepending

Speaker

Adam Elga

Evidence Quote

“you basically should defer to what your prior self would have thought... we ask that past version of yourself, what would you think conditional on that?”

Source

345 | Adam Elga on Being Rational in a Very Large Universe— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:24:14 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...