normative
British Empire benefits outweighed costs
A rigorous cost-benefit analysis with realistic counterfactuals shows the British Empire was a remarkably benign empire compared with available alternatives, including indigenous empires; in the 19th century it became an empire of free trade, free migration, and free capital movement that turned away from slavery before others, making it a positive force—while critics who liken it to the Third Reich commit category errors and posit unrealistic counterfactuals.
normativepending
Speaker
Niall FergusonEvidence Quote
“those people on the left who make a living out of comparing the empire to the Third Reich are just not being rigorous. They're committing category errors, and more importantly, they're not positing realistic counterfactuals.”
Created: 6/12/2026, 4:55:28 PM
Your notes
Loading notes...