normative
But-For Criterion Needs Formal Causal Grounding
The legal 'but-for' criterion—a defendant is liable only if the victim would have lived but for the defendant's action—has no precise meaning in colloquial legal use until grounded in the formal causal algorithm as a necessary cause exceeding 50% probability, and AI fairness concerns will push the legal profession to adopt these necessary/sufficient cause definitions.
normativepending
Speaker
Judea PearlEvidence Quote
“But for has no meaning in the colloquial conversations among lawyers unless you put it in a firm scientific basis. And the algorithm is the definition of 'but for'.”
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:18:40 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...