causal
Conceptual Replications Created Illusion of Confirmation
Roughly 300 papers cited the original priming study as 'conceptual replications,' each testing slightly different conditions and finding some pattern, which created an overwhelming illusion of confirmation; this is itself a forking-paths problem because contradictory results can always be rationalized into apparent support.
causalpending
Speaker
Andrew GelmanEvidence Quote
“This can go on forever. There's really no way of stopping it. The only way of stopping it, perhaps, is to do... brute force running a replication.”
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:23:45 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...