The Native American tragedy was a Greek (fated) tragedy rather than a Shakespearean (contingent) one because demography overwhelmed any plan of justice: Native Americans between the Alleghenies and Mississippi were roughly 80,000 against 500 Anglo-Americans at the Treaty of Paris, but by 1800 had fallen to 50,000-60,000 against 500,000 white settlers, and the weak federal government had no power to stop the influx.

causalpending

Speaker

Joseph Ellis

Evidence Quote

“demography defeats all other plans of of Justice they just can't stop it and federal government doesn't have the power to do so”

Source

Joseph Ellis on American Creation and the Founding 09/08/2008— EconTalk
Created: 6/16/2026, 2:38:17 PM

Your notes

Loading notes...