Averaging biased views doesn't always work. As UCLA econometrician Ed Leamer showed, with the same death-penalty data set a proponent can reasonably show each execution deters 30 murders, while an opponent, using a different specification and slightly different variables, can show each execution causes 12 murders. Leamer's conclusion is not to take the average but that the data don't let us answer the question, and Roberts thinks the same may be true of depression treatments.

causalpending

Speaker

Russ Roberts

Evidence Quote

“his conclusion isn't take the average his conclusion which I think is the correct one... the data don't let us answer the question”

Source

Louis Menand on Psychiatry 05/31/2010— EconTalk
Created: 10/29/2026, 7:34:04 PM

Your notes

Loading notes...