causal

First oxygenation event constrained rather than helped

Because a small amount of oxygen suppresses multicellular size, the first Great Oxidation Event (~2.1 billion years ago) likely acted as a constraint on multicellular complexity rather than a catalyst, consistent with the geological 'Boring Billion' of low apparent biospheric change, whereas only the later rise to near-modern oxygen levels ~500 million years ago enabled the flowering of multicellular diversity.

causalpending

Speaker

William Ratcliff

Evidence Quote

“during that low oxygen boring billion, oxygen may in fact have acted as a constraint.”

Source

175 | William Ratcliff on Multicellularity, Physics, and Evolution— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:24:43 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...