causal

Explanation requires counterfactuals not just events

Scientific explanation, unlike mathematical explanation, routinely cites not just what happens but what would have happened under different conditions; for example, Newton's inverse-square law explains orbital precession by entailing that orbits would not precess absent other planets, and making sense of such explanatory counterfactuals is where the anti-Humean argues we need robust laws.

causalpending

Speaker

Ned Hall

Evidence Quote

“if there had been no other planets then this orbit would not have precessed... it looks like an explanation that cites, not just facts about what does happen, but facts about what would have happened”

Source

76 | Ned Hall on Possible Worlds and the Laws of Nature— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:19:13 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...