normative

Crude rules fit vague, unknowable situations

When a situation is vague, ambiguous, and fundamentally unknowable—like the full range of bank risks—an overstructured, tidy-minded attempt to assign a precise risk weight to everything is unsuitable, and a very crude approach may be better; thus the Basel rules can be read as a tidy-minded over-engineering failure, while the simple one-rule pile is a 'tidy mess.'

normativepending

Speaker

Tim Harford

Evidence Quote

“If you've got vague and ambiguous and unknowable situation, a very crude approach may be better.”

Source

Tim Harford on the Virtues of Disorder and Messy— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:25:48 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...