factual
No natural language semantics settles the metaphysics
There is probably no determinate natural-language semantics for moral claims — people mean different things, and emotivists at the turn of the 20th century held 'good' merely expresses 'yay' or 'boo,' which cannot be true or false — but this question of what people are doing when they utter moral words is independent of the metaphysical question: one can stipulatively introduce a language about how we ought to live independent of anyone's opinion, and belief in those facts is on as good footing as belief in numbers, yet still does not settle practical questions.
factualpending
Speaker
Justin Clarke-DoaneEvidence Quote
“you might be right about natural language semantics, but I don't see how that settles the metaphysics”
Source
137 | Justin Clarke-Doane on Mathematics, Morality, Objectivity, and Reality— Sean Carroll's MindscapeCreated: 6/13/2026, 12:21:37 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...