definition

Counterfactuals via Mentaculus Macrostate Probabilities

Counterfactuals should be evaluated not by Lewis's similarity-and-miracle approach but by using the Mentaculus probability distribution: condition on the macroscopic state of the universe at a time when the antecedent (e.g., the match being struck) is reasonably likely, then read off the probabilities the Mentaculus assigns to later macroscopic events (whether oxygen is present, the match is dry, whether it lights)—thereby giving truth conditions for counterfactuals without ever violating the laws.

definitionpending

Speaker

Barry Loewer

Evidence Quote

“let's just think about The Mentaculus probability distribution... given the macroscopic state of the universe at that time, that will entail things in accordance with The Mentaculus about what will be going on at later times”

Source

215 | Barry Loewer on Physics, Counterfactuals, and the Macroworld— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:02:57 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...