factual

Intention-to-Treat Effect Is About One Quarter

Because only about 25-30% of lottery winners actually received Medicaid, the intention-to-treat effect (the causal effect of winning the lottery) is roughly one quarter of the reported treatment effect; you can divide the headline per-person effects by four, and Manzi's critique of the study only strengthens under this stricter analysis.

factualpending

Speaker

Jim Manzi

Evidence Quote

“all the arguments that I made in that essay simply become a lot stronger if I just take all the effects and divide by 4. Which is what you would do on an intend-to-treat basis.”

Source

Jim Manzi on the Oregon Medicaid Study, Experimental Evidence, and Causality— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:13:56 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...