factual

Pessimism line: even worst-case life odds imply prior civilizations

By manipulating the Drake equation against exoplanet data, Frank and Sullivan derived a 'pessimism line': the per-planet odds of forming a civilization would have to be below 10^-22 for us to be the only civilization in the observable universe; since even the most pessimistic literature estimates (around 10^-20) exceed this, the math implies on the order of a hundred civilizations have existed before us.

factualpending

Speaker

Adam Frank

Evidence Quote

“How bad does the per-planet odds for forming a civilization have to be to make us the only ones in the universe... And that answer turns out to be 10 to the minus 22... which would mean that there's a hundred civilizations before us”

Source

259 | Adam Frank on What Aliens Might Be Like— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:22:14 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...