factual

Entropy Is Real But Not Fundamental

The second law of thermodynamics and entropy are not fundamental — Laplace's demon, knowing the exact microstate, would have no ignorance and thus no entropy — but they are real in the sense that entropy is a higher-level emergent concept with genuine causal and explanatory power; this exemplifies Carroll's general view that there are better and worse ways of dividing the world into objects, where a collection counts as real if it has a causal role and an autonomous higher-level theory, unlike an arbitrary collection (your foot plus a coffee cup plus an oak tree).

factualpending

Speaker

Sean Carroll

Evidence Quote

“there are right and wrong ways of doing it, there are better and worse ways of dividing the world into objects.”

Source

AMA | July 2021— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:22:53 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...