causal

Irreversibility and noise, not symmetry-breaking, underlie macro arrow

What gives macroscopic processes their arrow of time is not the esoteric microscopic symmetry violations (like certain particle decays) but irreversibility (many initial states funneling into one final state, losing information) and noise (de facto unpredictability of which future state is reached); these wash out information, which is why we can predict but not retrodict macroscopic processes like a melting ice cube.

causalpending

Speaker

David Wallace

Evidence Quote

“What I think matters in the way these dynamics run differently, forward and backwards, is they have irreversibility and they have noise. Irreversibility, meaning you lose information, lots of different initial states come together and end up in the same final state. Noise in the sense that it becomes, at least de facto, impossible to predict which of many future states the system is going to make its way into. And those features of irreversibility and noise wash out information”

Source

158 | David Wallace on the Arrow of Time— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:26:31 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...