normative

History Should Use Causes Not Reasons

Good history is possible when done free from the theory of mind: rather than appealing to reasons (beliefs and desires), it should appeal to causes—physically concrete factors and forces such as strategic situations of nations—which produce real understanding of the past and from which lessons can be learned.

normativepending

Speaker

Alex Rosenberg

Evidence Quote

“There are factors and forces whose physical concrete existence is undeniable and which result in vast and less vast changes in human affairs over time. That's history. I think there are lots of great examples of how to do history completely free from the theory of mind”

Source

125 | David Haig on the Evolution of Meaning from Darwin to Derrida— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:09:50 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...