normative
Counterintuitive Results May Signal Wrong Theory
When a moral theory produces highly counterintuitive or weird suggestions, this can be evidence that the theory is wrong, since for a moral anti-realist our moral intuitions are the starting point and a system wildly in conflict with them may have been built badly—though it could also mean we should discard a flawed intuition.
normativepending
Speaker
Sean CarrollEvidence Quote
“it's evidence when the system that I've tried to build is wildly in conflict with the intuitions I started with, that might be either because I gotta get rid of that intuition or because I did a bad job building a system”
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:30:07 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...