Per Bak defended his sandpile theory against the criticism that real sandpiles don't follow power laws by claiming 'self-organized criticality only applies to the systems it applies to,' prioritizing the universal mechanism over matching real-world sandpile behavior because he was interested in a universal mechanism for generating power laws rather than sandpile accuracy.
factualpending
Speaker
Derek MullerEvidence Quote
“'Self-organized criticality only applies to the systems it applies to'... He's interested in bigger fish to fry than sandpiles... a universal mechanism for generating power laws.”
Created: 8/11/2026, 7:21:07 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...