factual

Science Progresses By Accumulated Weight

Science—including physics and chemistry—progresses not through single 'thunderbolt' studies that decisively change thinking but through the accumulated weight of many studies using slightly different data, assumptions, and methods that produce consistent results; even establishing the charge of the electron took many iterative experiments, so the high rate of non-replicating studies in economics and psychology is normal and expected.

factualpending

Speaker

Noah Smith

Evidence Quote

“even on like the charge of the electron you had to get lots and lots of experiments before people fixed on what they really believe in... So, don't rely too much on these thunderbolt studies, even though sometimes they do exist. But they are pretty rare”

Source

Noah Smith on Whether Economics is a Science— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:23:15 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...