normative

Future Demented Self Is A Different Person

Advance directives about being lied to may be unfair because once dementia descends past a certain level of memory and cognitive function you are not really 'you' anymore, so imposing a present self's harsh preference for no lies on a future, vulnerable self who likely no longer holds that value—and who would be made to weep daily—may be wrong, and also burdens the caregiver who is distressed by that distress.

normativepending

Speaker

Larissa MacFarquhar

Evidence Quote

“Is it fair to impose this harsh discipline of no lies on a future you who actually has very little in common with the you sitting across from me now”

Source

Larissa MacFarquhar— Conversations with Tyler
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:29:46 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...