normative

Reliable Prophet Justifies Letting Drowning Child Die

In the real world you should save the person drowning in front of you because you cannot know the future, but if a perfectly reliable prophet told you that saving this one person would prevent a successful career that would let you donate millions and thereby save thousands of lives, then it would be right to let the person in the pond drown, even though it would be emotionally difficult.

normativepending

Speaker

Peter Singer

Evidence Quote

“then I would say, you would be right to let the person in the pond drown. It would be hard to do, it would be emotionally very difficult because this person is right in front of you.”

Source

Peter Singer on The Life You Can Save— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:29:09 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...