causal

Innate gender differences cannot be read off current data

Just as Mill thought it ridiculous to ascertain women's innate orientations under 19th-century patriarchal conditions, it is epistemically naive to infer innate male/female differences from data like Iran vs the Nordics, because gendering begins in infancy—children identify gendered toys pre-verbally and parents interact differently with boy and girl infants—so no known society is distant enough from this conditioning to reveal what humans are innately like.

causalpending

Speaker

Amia Srinivasan

Evidence Quote

“The idea that there's any example of a known society where we're so distant from that, such that we can start to get a good grip on what women and men are innately like, I think, is epistemically naive.”

Source

Amia Srinivasan— Conversations with Tyler
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:05:10 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...