causal

Functionalism and simulation may be insufficient for consciousness

An exact physical duplicate of a person would be conscious (a statement of materialism), but it does not follow that consciousness is substrate-independent or that simulation suffices, because the hardware/software distinction may not cleanly apply to brains where dynamics and structure continually reshape each other; like a simulated hurricane that doesn't get wet, simulation may not instantiate phenomenal properties even though it instantiates chess-playing.

causalpending

Speaker

Anil Seth

Evidence Quote

“to just assume that conscious consciousness is the kind of thing that can be instantiated through simulation is just to fully take on board functionalism and metaphors of information that i think are plausible but i don't think should be taken for granted”

Source

113 - Consciousness And The Self— Making Sense with Sam Harris
Created: 6/14/2026, 1:55:20 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...