causal

Parmesan-Vomit Shows Context Determines Quality

Rachel Hertz's 2001 experiment gave people the identical butyric-acid mixture labeled either 'parmesan' or 'vomit' and they were adamant the smells differed and preferred parmesan; rather than proving smell is unreliable illusion, this shows both labels are correct because butyric acid occurs in both, demonstrating that a single promiscuous stimulus carries different behavioral meanings depending on context, which the olfactory system must resolve.

causalpending

Speaker

Ann-Sophie Barwich

Evidence Quote

“both parmesan and vomit do contain butyric acid. You have certain molecules in different context, giving you completely different meanings, in this case, food and contaminants.”

Source

105 | Ann-Sophie Barwich on the Science and Philosophy of Smell— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:06:35 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...