causal

Why Economists Resist Signaling

Mainstream labor economists remain skeptical of signaling for several non-evidentiary reasons: the best evidence lies outside economics (in educational psychology and sociology) and is ignored on disciplinary grounds; distinguishing signaling from human capital requires extra work beyond a simple income-education regression; a functionalist bias assumes whatever exists socially makes sense ('how come every country does it this way'); researchers were lifelong good students who romanticize education and engage in 'intellectual incest' by using what they studied; and left-leaning enthusiasm plus bipartisan appeal make subsidizing education attractive.

causalpending

Speaker

Bryan Caplan

Evidence Quote

“in economics, it's a lot easier to advance by going and solidly proving a fact than by convincingly arguing that the fact means something important.”

Source

Bryan Caplan on the Case Against Education— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:16:17 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...