normative

Camping Trip Is Invalid Metaphor For Economy

G.A. Cohen's camping-trip parable—where organizing chores by a market would seem crazy among friends—is valid for a camping trip but a bad metaphor for the whole economy, because the trip involves only 6-10 people doing simple, roughly equal tasks while relying on gear (tents, pots, clothing) whose production required millions of coordinated tasks the parable pretends away, and because in the real world people's talents, inclinations, and the desirability of tasks differ, so getting people to be sanitation workers or chicken farmers without pay requires heavy-handed coercion.

normativepending

Speaker

Arnold Kling

Evidence Quote

“you are pretending that all those problems of coordination didn't exist, when you say that the whole economy can be run like a camping trip”

Source

Arnold Kling on Specialization and Trade— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:09:29 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...