factual

Brain regions for cost-benefit vs all-things-considered judgment

When asked which footbridge action produces better results, people show more activity in the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (conscious explicit reasoning and cognitive control); when asked for an all-things-considered judgment, more activity appears in the ventromedial prefrontal cortex (damaged in Phineas Gage), which serves as a hub integrating decision-relevant signals, including the amygdala's emotional 'don't' and the reasoning system's cost-benefit.

factualpending

Speaker

Joshua Greene

Evidence Quote

“what the VMPFC seems to do is serve as a hub for signals that bear on decision-making... So you've got the amygdala saying, 'Ah, don't do that,' and you've got your dorsolateral prefrontal cortex saying, 'Well, but isn't saving five lives better than one'”

Source

176 | Joshua Greene on Morality, Psychology, and Trolley Problems— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:18:50 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...