Charity can be morally worse than impersonal government provision because it creates a demeaning dependency between recipient and donor (groveling, doffing the hat), whereas treating benefits as entitlements that all members get by right removes that texture; the highest form of charity, per Maimonides, is when both donor and recipient are anonymous (as with blood donation).

normativepending

Speaker

Debra Satz

Evidence Quote

“there's a demeaning relationship between the recipient and the donor in a charity case”

Source

Debra Satz on Markets 08/08/2011— EconTalk
Created: 6/17/2026, 12:21:01 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...