factual

Finite Hilbert Space Idea Ruled Out by Observation

The Banks-Fischler proposal that quantum gravity for our universe has only a finite number of states (a finite-dimensional Hilbert space matched to our cosmological constant) was compelling enough to pursue, but the Dyson-Kleban-Susskind argument that such a theory is inconsistent with observation led Bousso to reject it and embrace the string theory landscape; he now guesses the fundamental Hilbert space is infinite-dimensional, while cautioning that whether quantum gravity even uses standard quantum mechanics is unsettled.

factualpending

Speaker

Raphael Bousso

Evidence Quote

“it was only this argument of Dyson, Kleban and Susskind that that theory is necessarily inconsistent... with observation. And at that point, I guess I embraced the landscape and moved on.”

Source

218 | Raphael Bousso on Black Holes and the Holographic Universe— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:23:45 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...