factual

Physicalism makes truths about fictional objects contingent

On strict physicalism, Sherlock Holmes exists only insofar as physical representations and cognitive practices sustain him, so if all instantiations were destroyed there would be no remaining truths about Holmes—an implication many find unintuitive; if one resists this for consciousness (subjective experience resistant to physical reduction), what principled reason distinguishes the two cases?

factualpending

Speaker

Chris Kaltwasser

Evidence Quote

“what principled reason is there to resist a similar move in the case of consciousness—where subjective experience seems equally resistant to reduction to physical description alone?”

Source

AMA | Feb 2026— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:30:56 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...