The meaning of constitutional provisions like 'advice and consent' was settled through messy improvisation and trial and error rather than design, as shown when Washington went physically to the Senate to seek treaty advice, found it unworkable, and after returning once more established that advice and consent does not require presidential presence in the Senate chamber.

factualpending

Speaker

Joseph Ellis

Evidence Quote

“the meaning of the language gets worked out in almost all the cases in these kind of messy improvisation trial and error”

Source

Joseph Ellis on American Creation and the Founding 09/08/2008— EconTalk
Created: 6/16/2026, 2:38:17 PM

Your notes

Loading notes...