causal

Self-Undermining Instability Cuts Both Ways

The Boltzmann brain argument generates a two-directional instability analogous to the hallucinated-memory case: concluding you are a Boltzmann brain undermines trust in the apparent memories and science that led to that conclusion (since Boltzmann brains never went to school), pushing you back to thinking you are an ordinary human—which revives the original argument—so the worry oscillates in both directions, not just one.

causalpending

Speaker

Adam Elga

Evidence Quote

“Boltzmann brains never went to school. They never read a textbook. They have no reason to think that anyone has ever looked through a telescope... They're just random blobs.”

Source

345 | Adam Elga on Being Rational in a Very Large Universe— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:24:14 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...