causal

Evolution cannot cross fitness valleys

Because evolution proceeds by small steps, it generally cannot reach a more advantageous state if the only route there passes through a less-fit valley; this is why the anaerobic yeast, having lost nearly all their mitochondrial genome, will likely never re-evolve oxygen use, and why horizontal gene transfer and synthetic biology are powerful, allowing valley-crossing or moving machinery between disparate lineages.

causalpending

Speaker

William Ratcliff

Evidence Quote

“that's the reason that synthetic biology, I think, has potential to do really cool things that you wouldn't expect to evolve, because you would have never been able to put these things together, either valley-crossing or just moving machinery from one disparate lineage into another.”

Source

175 | William Ratcliff on Multicellularity, Physics, and Evolution— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:24:43 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...