causal
Cohen's Camping Trip Doesn't Scale to Society
Cohen's camping-trip case for socialism works only because it is a highly stylized small group of people who know each other, share one or two purposes, and gather for a limited duration; a society of over 300 million strangers with divergent values cannot rely on the face-to-face personalized knowledge that makes the camping model possible, so the model is not transferable and in fact won't work at scale.
causalpending
Speaker
James OttesonEvidence Quote
“It's that once you get out of a very small group, that kind of scenario is just no longer possible. We have to find alternative ways of associating with one another... relying on that kind of deep personalized knowledge where you actually look each other in the eye is simply not going to be transferable to a large scale society.”
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:13:27 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...