factual

'Popped Into Existence' Smuggles In Time

The phrase 'popped into existence' is the wrong way to describe a universe with a beginning because it assumes time already exists—a moment with no universe followed by a moment with one; if the Big Bang is the first moment there was no 'before', so going backward from now you simply hit an end rather than a creation event.

factualpending

Speaker

Sean Carroll

Evidence Quote

“In the scenario where the universe has a beginning, where the Big Bang is the start. There was no moment before the Big Bang. The Big Bang was just the first moment, it didn't pop into existence.”

Source

9 | Solo -- Why Is There Something Rather than Nothing?— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:16:31 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...