causal

Volunteer Armies Loyal to Commanders

When Marius raised an army from propertyless volunteers rather than property-holding citizens, those soldiers became loyal to their commander rather than the state because their retirement and discharge bonuses depended on the political fortunes of the general who recruited them; this forced every subsequent commander to do the same, creating private armies that could be used as political tools through implicit threat.

causalpending

Speaker

Edward Watts

Evidence Quote

“You're loyal to your commander, you're serving the state but your loyalty is to your commander. And the minute your commander is not loyal to the state he could ask you to choose.”

Source

37 | Edward Watts on the End of the Roman Republic and Lessons for Democracy— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:25:21 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...