factual
Statistical probability is empirical, not a priori counting
The robust notion of probability in statistical mechanics is not obtainable a priori by counting possibilities; the assumption that each microstate compatible with a macrostate is equally likely is a substantive empirical claim, evidenced because equations derived from it get experiments right, not because it follows logically from there being many possible states.
factualpending
Speaker
David WallaceEvidence Quote
“I think we've got a ton of evidence from the actual application of physics that there's some robust notion of probability in statistical mechanics, but I also think we've got quite a lot of reason to think that that notion of probability is not something we can get at a priori from just counting possibilities.”
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:26:31 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...