causal

Convergent evolution like wings selecting for vocal learning

Vocal learning evolving in wildly different species is convergent evolution analogous to wings, which independently evolved in bats, birds, and ancient flying dinosaurs always at the sides of the body due to the physical selection pressure for aerodynamic center of gravity—nature repeatedly selects for the same trait given similar constraints, and spoken language is the same kind of repeated solution.

causalpending

Speaker

Erich Jarvis

Evidence Quote

“it's kind of like the evolution of wings. They evolve in bats and birds, some ancient flying dinosaurs, and each time it's at the sides of the body”

Source

127 | Erich Jarvis on Language, Birds, and People— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:23:44 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...