factual
Formal system is interconnected, not circular
The circularity argument fails because, while individual terms like mass cannot be defined in isolation, one defines an entire formal system (e.g., spacetime as a four-dimensional Lorentzian manifold) with well-defined parts, and then maps that whole formal structure onto the data of experience—this is interconnected, not viciously circular, and a field can simply be identified as a section of a fiber bundle, requiring no appeal to intrinsic nature.
factualpending
Speaker
Sean CarrollEvidence Quote
“I don't think it's circular, I do think it's interconnected... If I don't care about what it really is, if I just care about where it is in the math, then I'm done.”
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:10:44 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...