normative

Compare voluntary provision to coercive status quo

Brennan's 'compared to what?' joke reframes the public-goods debate: voluntary, crowd-sourced provision of local public goods should be judged not against an ideal but against the existing coercive system in which decisions are made with little information and tax money is taken 'basically at gunpoint,' against which voluntary provision tied to what people actually care about may well be an improvement.

normativepending

Speaker

Michael Munger

Evidence Quote

“we're taking tax money basically at gunpoint. The alternative would be: What is it that people really care about, and they get the sense of participation?”

Source

Michael Munger on Sharing, Transaction Costs, and Tomorrow 3.0— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:19:52 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...