normative

Gray owes an alternative solution to the meaning problem

There is philosophical pressure to accept progress as the solution regardless of one's views on religion: if you grant Scheffler's premise that meaning depends on future generations and reject the internalist solution, you need some solution, and progress is one; rejecting it requires offering a different one, and if Gray bites the bullet that life is meaningless he should live accordingly—if he doesn't, he is operating under the very religious ideas he accuses others of holding.

normativepending

Speaker

Agnes Callard

Evidence Quote

“If he really thought life was meaningless, I would expect him to live in accordance with that idea... if it doesn't, then I might just not believe him, that he really thinks that.”

Source

Agnes Callard on Meaning, the Human Quest, and the Aims of Education— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:08:09 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...