normative
Mandate Penalties Should Be Proportionate
Even if a vaccine mandate is justified, the penalty should be proportionate to the evidence—historically a modest fine ($100-200)—not loss of employment plus a perpetual industry-wide prohibition on rehire, which amounted to an effective 'death penalty' that ruined lives and violated longstanding public health ethics.
normativepending
Speaker
Vinay PrasadEvidence Quote
“I think penalty should be proportionate to the evidence as well, and that's a longstanding principle of public health ethics. It was entire overkill.”
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:19:32 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...