factual

The Repugnant Conclusion and Its Inescapability

Total utilitarianism implies the repugnant conclusion: a sufficiently vast population of lives barely worth living has greater total well-being than a smaller population of blissful lives; Parfit found this repugnant, but a step-by-step argument (dominance addition, then equalizing, iterated, with transitivity) shows you must reject one of several highly compelling principles or accept the conclusion—so every population-ethics view faces an impossibility result.

factualpending

Speaker

William MacAskill

Evidence Quote

“you either have to say that at some point the move from something like the A world to the A plus world is bad, or that move from the A plus world to the B world is bad. Or you have to deny transitivity... Or you have to accept the repugnant conclusion.”

Source

207 | William MacAskill on Maximizing Good in the Present and Future— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:14:05 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...