Crowding-out objections to government R&D spending fail on current margins because private firms only invest in R&D that is sufficiently predictable, timely (profitable within ~5-10 years), and cost-effective; the most valuable scientific breakthroughs are inherently unpredictable and cross-disciplinary, so firms won't fund them anyway—removing the crowd-out concern for exactly those areas.

causalpending

Speaker

Caleb Watney

Evidence Quote

“if private companies are not going to be spending on these areas anyways because it's sufficiently untimely sufficiently unconnected and not sufficiently profitable um then yeah you have way less concern about uh crowd”

Source

Caleb Watney - America's Innovation Engine— Dwarkesh Patel
Created: 6/13/2026, 7:00:44 PM

Your notes

Loading notes...